Skipping around some weblogs run by Cardinals fans, the reaction to the Mulder for Haren/Calero/Barton trade is universally this: where the hell did that come from?!?! Here’s a roundup:
Bellyscratcher at Belly Itcher says, “This came out of nowhere.” He thinks Calero will be the most missed of the three headed to Oaktown, and wonders whether Lincoln or Reyes will be able to fill his role as a dependable setup man. If Lincoln returns to his pre-injury form of early last season, he most certainly will. And if La Russa doesn’t overwork him again.
Scott Humphries at All in the Cards managed to score a telephone interview with Mulder. He’s gonna miss playing with the A’s, but is excited about coming to St. Louis. He prognosticates that the Cards have a very good chance at defending their pennant. Nice work, Scott.
Robb at Random Redbird Musings gets the award for obvious jokes, with an X-Files reference in the Mulder post’s title. He asks, “Am I the only one who was blind-sided by this trade?” No, you most certainly are not. He notes that all five of the Cardinals projected starters won 15 games last season. Super nice! In a more recent post, he comments on the possibility of picking up free agents David Eckstein and Alex Cora to plug the personnel hole in our middle infield, providing a surprising statistics to argue that Eckstein and Cora would represent an improvement over Womack and Renteria. Actually, his conclusion is less bold: “they would likely – at worst – be a slight downgrade defensively over the 2004 Cardinals.” I don’t know much about Eckstein, but he sounds an awful lot like Bo Hart. Good defensive skills, slappy contact hitter, fan favorite youthful sort…
Dan at Get Up, Baby, Get Up! (I’d love to build an alarm clock that loops Mike Shannon’s trademark call in lieu of the beeping beeps) doesn’t like the trade. He’s trying to like it, but can’t seem to get over that hump. His reasoning for hating the trade is that Mulder’s late season numbers were freakishly bad. That makes sense to me–Mulder faded hard last year, and if he doesn’t pull up and pitch like he has for his entire career again, then the Cardinals will have been royally screwed by Billy Beane. And he cites the JD Drew/Eli Marerro trade to Fatlanta for Jason Marquis (a fifteen game winner last season), Sweet Baby Ray (one of two kickass lefties in our bullpen with Ankiel–and a fine baserunner, believe it or not), and Adam Wainwright (a stud prospect who apparently had some problems with shoulder weakness when he came over, and spent most of last season injured), huff… huff… cites that trade as an example of Jocketty’s weird trades. JD Drew was arguably the Braves best player last season, and I’ve always been a big Eli fan, but I liked the trade at the time and like it now. We needed pitching at the time. It was a very good trade for the Cardinals. He also cites the Tatis for Hermanson and Kline trade as another example. Tatis was coming off a great pair of seasons offensively… in 1999 he hit two grand slams in the same inning off the same Pitcher (Chan Ho Park of the Dodgers). In spite of all that, I wasn’t much of a Tatis fan. He struggled for power, and his percentages paid for it. And we needed pitching, and got it. Hermanson was a competent starter, and Kline a great reliever. And now, Jocketty trades away our (numerically) best pitcher from the BP and two of our future stars for what could possibly be the best lefthanded starter of the next few years–a potential Cy Young candidate–to address our desparate need for a #1 starter, and it’s another of Jocketty’s wacky trades? C’mon man! This is gonna work out. Let yourself get excited! And if the sky falls in and Mulder can’t pitch worth a damn next season, we’ll just have to swap Ankiel into the rotation. But I find that unlikely.
Some more displeasure is available at STL Outsider, concluding with “Last March a lot of talking heads wrote off the Cardinals because they didn’t have a Big Name pitching staff. In retrospect those people look like idiots as Jocketty got some unheralded starters to fill the innings, letting the position players carry the team defensively and offensively through a special summer. I’m really concerned that the Cardinals ignored what won them 112 of their first 173 games, and focused on those last four losses.” I politely disagree. Look at it this way: we swapped out Williams for Mulder. Haren spent 2004 in AAA for the most part, while I think he’s a great pitcher and a hell of a guy, I don’t think the Cardinals success in 2004 can be spoken of as though it hung in the balance of Danny Haren’s right hand. Calero was missing for much of the season. We got a left-handed starter who had a couple of bad months last season, preceded by a lifetime of ass-kicking. (Although some of the statistics that blog mentions are rather spooky. I’ll have to do my own calculations to verify.)
Beau Chapman at The Psychotic Cardinal has mixed feelings about the trade (at times bordering on psychotic, true to form). He recognizes Mulder as an upgrade over Haren, but doesn’t have confidence with a Calero-free (and Kline-free) bullpen. Barton’s exit from the Cardinals’ farm system terrifies him. I can relate to that, but I side with conventional wisdom in that he’ll never make the big leagues as a catcher.
David at Red Sea Scrolls (I dig the name) also bemoans the lame X-Files jokes we’ll be putting up with this season. He’s also rationally worried about Mulder’s decline in the second half of last season: “But after the break, he hit a wall…and we’re talking Berlin/Great Wall of China type wall here. His post ASB record was 5-6 with a nasty 6.13 ERA. Opponents hit almost .300 off of him. Ace he was not. Heck, Brett Tomko (v.2003) he was not.” He also takes (what I consider to be) the right attitude with respect to Barton: “All we can do now is wish him luck.” The conclusion is that the trade was (probably) a good idea.
That’s all the Cardinals weblogs I know of… the rest are either on hiatus or retired.