Practice was a blast tonight, I did a bit better in the field and was able to track down a few flyballs and field a few groundballs cleanly. Pitched a little more consistently too. Unfortunately, our team is still short two players, ideally two women.
Tonight’s Cardinals game has been a peach, too. I DVR’ed it and have caught it from the fourth or so on. Still watching it now… Miles just committed his first error as a Cardinal here in the ninth chasing down a flyball in right, with Pujols and Encarnacion right there. He played a solid second base today, though. The bullpen’s been solid. Looper pitched a scoreless seventh, Thompson a scary but scoreless eighth, and Hancock just got the fourth out of the ninth to finish the game. Cards win, 8-3… Tomorrow night, the Soup looks to bounce back from a lousy start last Friday. (Later: Ha! Edmonds joked in a postgame interview that he’s getting old and slow and that’s why he barely mishandled a flyball to the wall. If he had gotten that ball, it would have been an incredible play.)
Back to the post:
The Cardinals website today has a very nice piece on Skip Schumaker, including plenty of positive quotations about him from first-base/outfield coach (and batting practice pitcher) Dave McKay.
“He can be a complete, complete outfielder. He’s playing well enough right now. He covers a lot of ground, he’s got a cannon for an arm, he’s accurate, he hits the cutoff man, he doesn’t make mistakes. He makes the plays he’s supposed to make and more. He’s going to be a very, very good outfielder.”
So this round of prognostication is a two-parter. First, you have to guess who’s the first player called up: either Junior Spivey from AAA or Larry Bigbie from his rehab assignment. Aside from an 0-8 day, Spivey’s been hitting well, and running very well. Bigbie hasn’t yet started his rehab assignment, although he should start on Monday when Memphis returns from a road trip, and he’s begun running in cleats. The second part of the prognostication game is to guess who’ll be sent down to Memphis to clear a roster spot for whichever player comes up. Most likely, the second part is dependent on whether you guess right for the first, since if Spivey comes up, an infielder would probably be sent down; if Bigbie comes up an outfielder would most likely be sent down. The twenty-five man roster is here.
My guess is that Spivey will stay in AAA until he either starts consistently making AAA pitching look silly or until the second base position in St. Louis deteriorates to the point of desperation. I’m not sure that either of these things will happen all season, and it wouldn’t surprise me if Spivey either stays in Memphis until he’s needed as to replace an injured player or he’s included in a trade package at some point this summer. (And I like Junior Spivey, who’s currently got a .406 OBA through six games in Memphis.) When Bigbie goes into his AAA rehab assignment, he’ll be joining a very crowded outfield with Chris Duncan in left, Shaun Boyd Prentice Redman in center, and John Gall in right with Prentice Redman Shaun Boyd in reserve. Bigbie will probably take Boyd’s spot for the majority of his assignment, playing center field (so as not to take time away from Duncan) and hitting lead-off to guarantee him the most at-bats per game. The Cardinals organization traded Ray King for Larry Bigbie, with Aaron Miles as a throw-in who didn’t quite fit in with the Rockies’ plans. They want Larry Bigbie on the field with the big club and not taking away at-bats from the Memphis outfielders. I expect he’ll be up with the club by the end of April. So there’s my guess for part one: Larry Bigbie over Junior Spivey.
As for part two… I’ve already written that there’s no benefit to the organization in sending Skip Schumaker down. Shaun Boyd is coming along well as the centerfielder/leadoff-hitter in Memphis and Skip’s holding his own against ML pitching thus far. I’m not a huge fan of John Rodriguez, but he’s looked solid in the field from what I’ve seen so far and he’s about as good a bat off our bench as we’ve got. My guess is that the player to come off the 25 man roster, then, comes from the infield. Miles is the starting 2nd baseman, so the options are between Spiezio and Luna. Spiezio can play first, second, third, and the corner outfield. Luna can play second, short, third, and corner outfield. If Luna is sent down before Spivey comes up, Eckstein’s backup would be Miles–and Spiezio would have to start at second, where he started once last season for the first time since 1999. If Spiezio is assigned to Memphis, Pujols wouldn’t have a backup on the bench. But he missed only 8 starts at first last season (DHing for most of those days, I think). Yadier Molina has played first before, and I imagine Gary Bennett wouldn’t mind filling in if necessary. Our best option to backup first would be Jim Edmonds, who has had nine starts at first since joining the Cardinals–most recently in 2004. And if Skip stays on the roster when Bigbie comes back, I count four outfielders who could play a solid centerfield: Larry Bigbie, Skip Schumaker, So Taguchi, and Jimmy Ballgame. Juan Encarnacion’s got experience playing center as well, but I’d take any of the other four there over him. It makes sense to get Edmonds a few starts at first just to give his legs a rest from time to time. Hector Luna’s had a start at second so far in the young season; Scott Spiezio’s played an inning in left field and had four plate appearances, one of which resulted in a walk and the rest in outs. I don’t yet see that Spiezio’s got a role on the team that can’t be better filled by other people in the organization. Nothing against the guy–not that I’ve got anymore say than any other jerk with a free website–but I’ll go out on a limb and make the crazy prognostication that Scott Spiezio will be Rico Washington’s backup in Memphis once Larry Bigbie is called up.
Update: After looking ahead in the schedule, I can make two more predictions… Tomorrow’s lineup against Doug Davis practically makes itself. I bet Bennett will catch Soup again and Rodriguez starts in left. It wouldn’t surprise me terribly if Scott Rolen gets his first day off on Friday, with Spiezio getting his first start against Aaron Harang of the Reds. Rolen’s struggled mightily against Harang to a .258 OPS (in fifteen AB). Depending on how Spiezio does in that game, I may have to change my guess.