Those winter meetings can’t get here soon enough, I tell ya. The hot stove season is high times for bloggers of baseball, since it’s all BS and speculation—taking half-truths and attempting to put them together into a sensible whole.
Then the winter meeting come along and shock waves are made that tear down our sandcastles. In this post, I’ll make my sandcastle. Then I’ll sit on the shoreline with my toes in the wet sand and see how real it was when the tide rolls in.
First though, read this FJM’ing of Stephen A. Smith’s recent column. It takes good comedy to get me to laugh out loud at a computer screen and this is good comedy.
The big news recently is that the Cubs signed Alfonso Soriano to an EIGHT year, one hundred thirty six million dollar contract. He’ll be 31 at the start of next season, so will be 39 in the final year of the contract. He’s put up a career OPS of .835, peaking at .911 last season—a walk-year in which he put together a phenomenal 40-40 season with the bat while committing 11 errors while learning to play left field. In his favor, he led all outfielders with 22 assists, but you can credit that with baserunners underestimating his ability to field his position—I wouldn’t expect him to be anywhere near the league leaders in that category next season. All that being said, he figures to hit a ton of home runs at Wrigley over the next few years.
In any case, I’m glad he’s off the market and it’ll be fun to see him play often over the next 8 years. I’m happy the Cards didn’t sign him—it’s much better to see the Cards take gambles on players who look to have big seasons than overpay for players who already had their big season. You won’t read a better indictment of the deal than in this column.
————-
Let’s have some fun with roster matrices, eh? (Concept stolen from VeB.) Let’s start off with the roster filled with guaranteed contracts for 2007, with all deferred salary subtracted, to see where there are holes. I’m making a prognostication that Juan Encarnacion will have wrist surgery in the next two weeks and that he’ll miss the first two months of the season. This assumption means that he’d be very difficult to trade for those of you Juan-haters. I’m also assuming that Wainwright starts the season in the bullpen at least until Izzy returns from hip surgery.
Base Roster
| LINEUP |
BENCH |
ROTATION |
PEN |
Molina C(R) $600K |
Spiezio UT(B) $2.25m |
Carpenter RHP $7.8m |
Wainwright RHP $380K |
Pujols 1B(R) $12m |
— OF — |
Reyes RHP $380k |
Looper RHP $4.5m |
— 2B — |
— OF — |
— P — |
Kinney RHP $380k |
Rolen 3B(R) $10m |
Miles IF(B) $380K |
— P — |
Rincon LHP $1.45m |
Eckstein SS(R) $4.5m |
— C — |
— P — |
Johnson LHP $380K |
Duncan LF(L) $380K |
— IF Memphis |
— P Memphis |
Hancock RHP $380k |
Edmonds CF(L) $8m |
— UT Memphis |
— P Memphis |
Flores LHP $380k |
— RF — |
— OF Memphis |
— P Memphis |
— P Memphis |
Encarnacion RF(DL) $5m |
— C Memphis |
— P Memphis |
Izzy RHP(DL) $8.75m |
TOTAL $40.48m |
TOTAL $2.63m |
TOTAL $8.18m |
TOTAL $16.60m |
| OVERALL PAYROLL: |
$67.89m |
So to fill the 25-man roster, we’ll need three outfielders, at least one of them with minor-league options remaining; a second baseman; a utility middle infielder; a backup catcher; and three starting pitchers. Using the $100-105 range that
Micklasz claims DeWitt’s comfortable with, there’s about 32 to 37 million bucks available to fille those holes. To start, here are the players under our control, not including a whole slew of minor league players who don’t have a realistic shot at making the team. I’ve also tried to give whether they have option years remaining or not and their arbitration eligibility status as accurately as I could.
Aaron Miles IF (B) – Arb.
Skip Schumaker OF (L) – 1 Op
John Rodriguez OF (L) – 1 Op
Rick Ankiel OF (L)
Amaury Marti OF (R) – 3 Op
Michel Hernandez C (R)
Brian Esposito C (R)
Brendan Ryan SS (R) – 2 Op
Chris Narveson LHSP
Brian Falkenborg RHRP
Randy Keisler LHRP
Jorge Sosa RHP – Arb.
Brad Thompson RHRP – 1 Op
Andy Cavazos RHRP
Larry Bigbie and Carmen Cali were cut from the 40-man roster yesterday and so probably won’t stick in the organization. I had high hopes for Bigbie going into last season—if he doesn’t get any guaranteed offers, I’d be pleased to see him get a AAA offer with an NRI from the Cardinals. Undoubtedly, John Rodriguez and Brad Thompson will be re-signed to the new league minimum of $380,000 or a little bit more. So Taguchi and Jorge Sosa should be non-tendered and offered low-paying contracts—probably a significant paycut to around a half million for Sosa. He shouldn’t attract much interest, seeing as we were the only takers after he was DFA’d and he didn’t pitch much better once arriving with the Cards. It wouldn’t surprise me much if So Taguchi ended up signing with the Marlins to be an everyday center fielder. They need one and So put up better numbers than Willy Taveras last year. He also had a higher OBP than four regular CF’s including Eric Byrnes and the noodle-armed Juan Pierre, who just signed a 5-year, $45,000,000 contract with the Dodgers. Plus, So’d get to see plenty of Billy Wagner! I’ve been a fan of Skip Schumaker’s defense since his call-up in 2005 and think he could be a decent 4th outfielder bat. He didn’t have the 2006 in Memphis that I was hoping for, but he was trying to do the right things by taking pitches and attempting to draw walks as the lead-off man. Unfortunately, a lot of those pitches he took were third strikes.
An offensive upgrade at backup catcher would be nice. I’ve been suggesting Todd Greene, who’d be an improvement with the stick and in managing the running game (35.5% vs. Bennett’s 10.3% of stealers thrown out). The Cubs kind of screwed up the market with their $5.4m/2 deal with Blanco but Greene should stay on the market long enough for prices to drop to around $800,000 or so. If not, going with Michel Hernandez, who spent a portion of 2006 on the DL, instead of exposing him to waiver claims shouldn’t be too terrible. I heard reports last Spring Training that his defense is good and that he calls a good game.
I still like Callix Crabbe quite a bit but don’t think he’d work out being claimed in the major-league Rule 5 draft. If the Brewers have soured on him a bit, though, and make him available at the AAA-level Rule 5 draft, it would be a worthwhile investment to pick him up, I’d think. The Astros wisely added power/switch-hitting AAAA 2B Brooks Conrad to 40-man roster after his phenomenal, abbreviated AFL season in which he showed some versatility playing some centerfield. Second base won’t be solved via that route, in any case.
Given the current state of the baseball market—and influx of cash from the sale of the gNats and internet subscriptions and so forth, coupled with a weak free-agent class—the Cardinals should wait out this year’s free agents to as much an extent as they can manage. The strategy we should take is to offer arbitration to our three Type A free agents (Jeff Suppan, Jeff Weaver, and Jabba) and try to sign one of them. The worst case scenario here is that all three accept arbitration and we’re stuck paying around 20 million for those three players—given the market conditions, it’s unlikely any of them would accept arbitration and take multiple-year deals with other teams. It’s my guess that Weaver will come back on a two or three year deal at a figure that his 2006 (regular season) performance won’t at all justify. My feeling is that he’ll be underwhelmed with the offers he gets elsewhere and re-sign with the Cardinals for a multiple-year deal before the Winter Meetings are over instead of taking a shaky resume to arbitration for a one-year contract. Depending on which teams the other two of those players go to, we’ll have either an incredible or a very good 2007 draft with Luhnow pulling the levers.
I’d like to see a strategy by which we trade for some walk-year players who’ll likely be Type-A FA’s next year and do our best to develop talent to fill holes through the farm system. Specifically, I’d like to see us trade from what I perceive to be our glut of bullpen talent for a starting pitcher and a second baseman.
The second baseman is Marcus Giles, who’d slot in perfectly at the 2-hole and provide solid defense. Giles had a lousy year at the plate and is entering his final arbitration year in which he’s expected to earn in the ballpark of $6 million. The Braves need bullpen arms and also need to avoid paying that kind of salary, so such a trade shouldn’t be impossible to swing. I’m told by my friends who are Braves fans that his batting struggles were caused by his discomfort batting leadoff. His 2006 splits bear that out: .251/.334/.361 batting leadoff vs. .312/.379/.494 hitting second. In 2005, he hit .300/.369/.481 out of the 2-hole. It’ll be an uncharacteristically expensive year at second but worth it in the long-run with draft compensation to keep the pipeline fed. And you’d have to love all that offense, should it come back as I’m guessing it will. I’m not sure what package it would take to outbid the Padres for Giles, who are supposedly trying to get him straight-up for Scott Linebrink, but it’s safe to say that they wouldn’t be interested in Braden Looper, who struggled quite a bit in the NL East over the past few years. Ottavino is untouchable, no matter what. Ideally, we can wait until the Padres sign a Mark Loretta or whoever the Mets don’t sign, at which time Giles’ trade value figures to drop considerably. Walt Jocketty and John Shuerholz are said to have a good relationship—a mutually beneficial arrangement is in order. For roster matrix purposes, I’ll say Flores, Thompson and a low prospect whose name doesn’t rhyme with got-a-bean-oh. They need a lefty, Flores is a damned good one, in spite of his unexpectedly high walk rate in 2006.
The starting pitcher I’d love to see us trade for is Jake Westbrook, who is, inexplicably, possibly available by trade for veteran bullpen help, among other things. The Cubs, as that linked Q&A mentions, are hot in his pursuit. Westbrook would be an ideal pitcher for the Cardinals and could put up excellent numbers with a stout infield behind him. He’s an extreme groundball pitcher (3.01 in 2006), defends his position at a Gold Glove level, eats innings, has a good K:BB, and on top of that, had an OPS of 1.250 OPS in 2006. (That last one wasn’t meant seriously, of course). For Westbrook, I’d be happy to part with TJ, Rincon, Looper, and a prospect, then start the season with Narveson, repented ‘roider Troy Cate, Matt Perisho, and Randy Keisler competing for the two lefty bullpen spots. If the Tribe is seriously considering Danys Baez as closer material, surely Looper, who’s due for a bounce-back year and has 103 career saves and 73 holds, must be a reasonable option. I honestly have no idea what it would take to convince the Indians to part with Westbrook. I’ve never seen Fausto Carmona pitch, maybe he’s the next Big Thing for whom the way must be cleared at any cost. It sure would be unpleasant to see him pitching for the Cubs, though. Since this is my own sandcastle, I’ll have us trading Tyler Johnson, Braden Looper, and $1.5 million for Westbrook, so his salary will go into the matrix as $7.6 million.
To fill out the bench, I’d like to see Marshall McDougall signed to a split contract. He’d be just a big righty off the bench and ideally learn to play the outfield. We’d need another right handed reliever. I’m sure there’ll be plenty of them lying around after the signing flurry ends. I’d like to see Chad Bradford signed, but am sure someone will pay through the nose for him. I’m penciling in Champaign-native Matt Herges, who has GB tendencies, can get a strikeout, and doesn’t give up many HR’s. Behold:
| LINEUP |
BENCH |
ROTATION |
PEN |
Molina C(R) $600K |
Spiezio UT(B) $2.25m |
Carpenter RHP $7.8m |
Wainwright RHP $380K |
Pujols 1B(R) $12m |
Schumaker OF(L) $380k |
Reyes RHP $380k |
Kinney RHP $380k |
Giles 2B(R) $6m |
McDougall UT(R) $380k |
Weaver RHP $7.5m |
Herges RHP $800k |
Rolen 3B(R) $10m |
Miles IF(B) $380K |
Westbrook RHP $7600000 |
Hancock RHP $380 |
Eckstein SS(R) $4.5m |
Greene C(R) $800k |
Wright RHP $800k |
Sosa RHP $500K |
Rodriguez LF(L) $380K |
— Memphis |
— Memphis |
Rincon LHP $1.45m |
Edmonds CF(L) $8m |
— Memphis |
— Memphis |
Narveson LHP $380k |
Duncan RF(L) $380k |
— Memphis |
— Memphis |
Cates P Memphis |
Encarnacion RF(DL) $5m |
— Memphis |
— Memphis |
Izzy RHP(DL) $8.75m |
TOTAL $46.86m |
TOTAL $4.19m |
TOTAL $24.08m |
TOTAL $12.02m |
| OVERALL PAYROLL: |
$88.15m |
Plenty of room to sign Carp to an extension or overpay for Giles, bullpen help. Plenty of room to sign Vicente Padilla instead of my perennial favorite 5th starter option Jamey Wright or an established right-handed OF instead of gambling that McDougall recovers well from wrist surgery.