My favorite current Cardinal is Scott Rolen. I love the way he plays baseball—if I have a son some day who likes the game, I’ll teach him to play with the same kind of class and dedication that Scott plays with. I love seeing him hit a key home run and circle the bases full-speed and head-down. Celebrating is for fans. Hitting and fielding is his job. True to form, he’s got a thoughtful, low-profile charity, the Enis Furley Foundation.
Scott’s career is currently derailed due to some hard-luck injuries stemming from on-field collisions and—perhaps more pertinently, personality clashes with Tony La Russa and the Cardinal organization in general. The current GM is open to trading Scott Rolen due to the problems he’s having with the organization and the VeB sidebar is littered with nonsensical trade proposals involving him. Given his trade value coming off an injury-plagued season, moving him elsewhere would be no more than a salary dump. A wasteful salary dump, motivated by fear or foolishness, in my opinion.
Mike Lowell was the 2007 World Series MVP. Two years ago, he was included in the big Hanley Ramirez and Anibal Sanchez for Josh Beckett trade between the Red Sox and the Marlins. At the time of the trade, I saw his inclusion as the wealthy Boston taking on a large contract for a broken-down third baseman in exchange for the Marlins parting with an ace pitcher for prospects. He was a throw-in, coming off an awful age-31 season with an OPS+ of 77. It was a smart move for the Marlins, who could use the cost-controlled Miguel Cabrera at third base and it was an acceptable trade requirement for the Red Sox, who could afford to gamble on Lowell bouncing back. He did, and is now most likely heading into a four year contract as a player a year older than Rolen.
Scott Rolen’s a better defender than Lowell and hasn’t ever had as bad a season as Lowell did in 2005, even the past few years when his shoulder pain has caused him to scream noticeably with every swing of the bat. To trade him for peanuts would be a real shame—a damned sin.
If I had John Mozeliak’s ear, I’d make sure that he was making every effort to make Rolen happy, to make him enthusiastic about playing in St. Louis for the rest of his career, or at least the remainder of his contract. I don’t know exactly what the problem is except that it stems from the handling of his shoulder injuries, but I’d make it clear that he’s a big part of our future plans. We’d make it clear that Mo will advocate on his behalf to La Russa and that whatever problems the organization had with dealing with medical problems are going to be fixed.
Scott Rolen’s got a lot of good baseball in him. The Cardinals are a wealthy-enough team that they shouldn’t have to play the Marlins and dump his contract to a richer team who can afford to gamble that he’ll be physically sound and producinc at an above average level in 2008 before reverting to his career arc in 2009.
(As insurance, we should sign Marshall McDougall to a split contract to compete with Spiezio as the big-bat utility guy or AAA depth at a number of positions. I said the same thing last off-season, when he went on to hit well for the Dodgers’ AAA team.)
In short, if the Cardinals can’t convince Scott Rolen to play for us next year, we’re in deep trouble as an organization. Mozeliak should work hard after the winter meetings to connect with Rolen and convince him that he’s wanted in a Cardinal uniform.
